An SEO audit tells you why your website isn’t ranking as well as it could, and what to fix first. You don’t need expensive software to do a useful one. This checklist covers what we look at when we audit a small business website, in the order we look at it.
You’ll need access to Google Search Console, your Google Business Profile and your website’s admin area.
1. Indexing
If Google can’t index your pages, nothing else matters.
- Search site:yourdomain.co.uk and check your important pages appear
- Open the Pages report in Search Console and review pages that aren’t indexed
- Make sure WordPress isn’t set to discourage search engines
- Check robots.txt isn’t blocking important sections
- Confirm your sitemap is submitted and has no errors
If you find problems here, our guide to why a website isn’t showing on Google explains the fixes.
2. Technical health
- The site loads over HTTPS with no security warnings
- Pages pass Core Web Vitals on mobile (see our website speed guide)
- The site works properly on a phone
- No broken internal links or pages returning errors
- Old URLs redirect to the right new pages
- Each page has one canonical version, with no duplicates on www and non-www or http and https
3. On-page basics
Check your homepage and each service page:
- A unique title tag under about 60 characters that includes the service and location
- A meta description that makes people want to click
- One H1 that says what the page is about
- Clear subheadings that break up the content
- Enough helpful content to answer what a customer would ask
- Images with descriptive alt text
- Internal links to related services and locations
4. Site structure and content
- Every main service has its own page
- You have pages for the main towns you serve, each with genuinely local content
- Important pages are no more than a couple of clicks from the homepage
- Your blog answers real customer questions and links to your service pages
- There’s no thin or duplicate content competing for the same keyword
5. Local SEO
For local businesses, this section often makes the biggest difference.
- Your Google Business Profile is verified and complete, with the right primary category
- Your business name, address and phone number match everywhere
- You’re listed on key directories such as Yell, Bing Places and Apple Business Connect
- You get new reviews regularly and reply to them
- Your website mentions your service area clearly
Our Google Business Profile checklist goes into this in detail.
6. Authority and links
- Check which sites link to you in Search Console’s Links report
- Look for easy local wins: suppliers, trade bodies, local business groups and sponsorships
- Disregard spammy links you didn’t build. Google mostly ignores them
7. Tracking
- Google Analytics 4 is installed and recording
- Form submissions and phone clicks are tracked as key events
- Search Console is linked to GA4
Without tracking, you can’t tell whether SEO is producing enquiries. See how to track website leads in GA4.
8. AI search visibility
More customers now ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google’s AI Overviews for recommendations. Clear service pages, consistent business details, reviews and helpful FAQs make you easier to recommend. Read how to get recommended by AI search.
How to prioritise what you find
Fix things in this order:
- Anything stopping pages from being indexed
- Problems affecting your Business Profile
- Missing service and location pages
- Speed and mobile issues
- Titles, descriptions and internal links
- Links and citations
Frequently asked questions
How often should I audit my website?
A light check every month in Search Console and a fuller audit once or twice a year is enough for most small businesses. Always audit before and after a website redesign.
Are free SEO audit tools accurate?
They’re useful for spotting technical issues, but they can’t judge content quality or local competition. Use them as a starting point, not a final verdict.
How much does a professional SEO audit cost?
Prices vary widely depending on the size of the site and depth of the audit. Many agencies, including us, offer a free initial audit for small businesses.
Want us to do it for you?
Book a free SEO audit and we’ll send you a clear, prioritised list of fixes for your website and Business Profile. See our SEO services or our work in Northamptonshire.







